Try out the new Bitbucket Cloud pull request experience today!

[Alastair Wilkes]

Thanks for the feedback. FYI, the new editor supports almost all Markdown (including `xyz` for inline code).

[Alastair Wilkes]

Hi Pavel, thanks for the feedback! This feature is noted in the documentation and will be returning soon. We appreciate you letting us know this feature is important to you!

[Alastair Wilkes]

@Hervé Le Meurthanks for the feedback, we're sorry the initial release has disappointed you.

Obviously critical bugs are not acceptable and must be dealt with immediately.

When it comes to deciding which features to include in a beta release (like the inline diff), it's definitely a tricky balance. For each existing feature, we had to decide whether the upside of that feature was worth the downside of keeping users from trying (and giving feedback on) the new features.

For the initial release, we prioritized features that we were confident were going to be useful all or almost all of the time by most users. Now we can use customer feedback like this to prioritize which additional features we need to bring back first, and users can opt-out if the new experience isn't sufficient for their needs yet.

Such is the benefit of doing a beta! Doing it this way helps us get the general availability release right, so we really appreciate you trying it out and giving feedback. Again, we take critical bugs seriously regardless of whether it's in a beta experience or not.

Thanks!

[Alastair Wilkes]

Dan, thanks for the warm feedback! I've passed it on to the team :)

[Deleted user]

One other bug I forgot to mention is the link to the JIRA ticket is not rendered in the title like it used to on the previous UI.

[Alastair Wilkes]

Hi Jiri,

Thanks for the feedback. The new editor is the only option for the new experience. We'll update the "Atlassian Editor" feature description to mention this.

[Alastair Wilkes]

Yes; over time you will see more Bitbucket pages adopt a similar design.

[Alastair Wilkes]

The ability to view prior comments will be shipping very soon. Stay tuned!

[Alastair Wilkes]

Glad you like it!

Yes, we plan to add that feature soon.

[Alastair Wilkes]

Thanks for the suggestion!

[Alastair Wilkes]

@Hervé Le Meur, would you mind sending us a link to that PR via a support ticket so we can investigate?

You can open one here: https://support.atlassian.com/bitbucket-cloud

We'd really appreciate it! Thank you.

[Dan Cumings]

Sometimes it is easy to focus on the issues with a new feature/system.  I wanted to be sure to also give my praises for this much needed/appreciated upgrade to pull requests.  Sometimes it feels like I spend half of my day doing pull requests.  Every small improvement you make directly affects my quality of life.  This is such a great update.  Keep up the good work!

[Alastair Wilkes]

Thanks for the report, Chris. A fix for that issue will be out soon.

[Alastair Wilkes]

That is very strange -- we will investigate it immediately! Thanks for reporting.

[Deleted user]

😲 that it, I'm turning it off for now, the feature needs to go back to the oven, it ain't done!

[Hervé Le Meur]

I had a really bad surprise today while code reviewing a PR.

With the new interface, a line was (incorrectly) marked as deleted:

When disabling the new UI, the same PR was indicating (correctly) the line as added:

Why? How is that possible?

[Chris Morse]

Individual file comment counts are  missing from the file tree in the side bar. Conflict indicators are working as expected. 

[MikeAshton]

The resize panel containing the file tree is slow to respond. There have been a number of times where I have over-shot with the mouse and (because the cursor didn't change shape in time) I clicked on the divider between the two sections. A second-or-so later, the panel registers the click and slowly collapses.

Sometimes I am sent very large pull requests which can take a long time to review. Is there any way of recording the files which have been reviewed (or even those which have been viewed)? This would be a lovely feature.

[Deleted user]

I'm seeing this issue too.

[Deleted user]

Any plan to make a similar view for the page when you're viewing a commit? It would be nice to have a unified theme like this all across Bitbucket.

[Deleted user]

BUG: Can't view older comments on file (clicking "1 prior comment" toggles file collapsing instead)

[Robert Parker]

Wow, this is fantastic! Is there a plan to make a convenient Collapse/Expand All feature?

[kgoss]

Looks great Atlassian Team!

I actually extended a plugin for my team that did a lot of these things like the sticky header and the collapsable files.

One of the main features my plugin does that would be a great additional feature here is allow you to collapse all files by the file type.

So for example, we have a lot of .test.snapshot files, which we don't always care to review, so you click a dropdown and select "Mark all .test.snapshot files as complete" and this will collapse all the snapshot files.

https://github.com/kgwebsites/bitbucket-pr-review

[Hervé Le Meur]

Nevermind, inline diffing is a WIP.

(Didn't found how to remove this comment.)

[Alastair Wilkes]

Sure thing!